top of page

A Guide to Eye Movement Desensitisation Reprocessing

Oct 12
6 min read

As trauma has in recent years grown ubiquitous in the discourse on mental health, EMDR has gained global recognition as an effective tool for addressing trauma. Even at the Psycho Soma, we've seen requests for EMDR come up more than any other form of therapy in new client enquiries over the past year. So if you are curious about exploring EMDR for yourself or a loved one, we hope this post helps orientate you. Here we outline what EMDR is, how it has become popularised as a therapy modality, who may benefit from EMDR, and what to be mindful of. We also expound on Attachment-Focused (AF) EMDR, the variation of EMDR that we practice at The Psycho Soma.


What is EMDR?

EMDR is best known as a trauma processing therapy, particularly as treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). First developed in the 1980s by Dr Francine Shapiro, EMDR's efficacy in trauma recovery has gained support by an extensive body of research. It is also endorsed by major health organisations like the World Health Organisation and American Psychiatric Association.


How does a session of EMDR work?

In short, a cycle of EMDR processing looks like this:

  1. Firstly, based on the presenting issue you are seeking to resolve in therapy (for example, anxiety associated with work), you and your therapist locate a target memory that might be associated with it.

  2. Next comes the desensitisation phase. Your therapist would guide you get in touch with the disturbing aspects of the target memory: sensations, emotions, and the negative thoughts that come with it. The experience is similar to watching a scene play out in your head. The therapist then initiates bilateral stimulation, i.e. a form of stimulation that alternates between left and right sides of the body. While traditional EMDR used side-to-side eye movements, therapists now offer other forms of bilateral stimulation such as handheld nodes that vibrate alternately, or audio tracks that emit sound left and right alternately. You may choose the form of bilateral stimulation that is the least distracting and most comfortable for you.

  3. Your therapist would guide you to allow your mind to unfold into its own stream of consciousness. Here there is no need to guide the mind in any way, to make sense of what comes up, or to zoom into details. While the processing began with the scene of the target memory, you may yourself moving through the scene to what happens next, to different memories, and these may not necessarily be in chronological order. Emotional intensity will rise, naturally in response to a distressing memory, then naturally fall as your brain is allowed to let the memory play out to completion. Your therapist's role is to provide a grounding presence to ensure the peaks of intensity are contained and that the mind does indeed move through a stream of consciousness, rather than stay stuck or "loop" in a particular distressing moment.

  4. After some time, your therapist will invite you to focus once again on the target memory to assess how intense or vivid it still feels. We know the target memory has been sufficiently processed when the following happens:

    1. The target memory has lost the vividness it had prior to processing. It becomes like any other neutral past experience that you try to recall – fuzzy, difficult to recall specific aspects, and a felt sense that it is in the past. It would be similar to trying to recall what your mundane Tuesday morning commute was like.

    2. When you think back to the target memory, you naturally arrive at a positive conclusion about what had happened. For example, "It's over. I survived" and "I was a child, it was not my fault."

    3. The target memory no longer comes with distressing emotions or sensations.

  5. If the target memory has indeed been sufficiently processed, you proceed to the installation phase. In this phase, the therapist uses bilateral stimulation to strengthen connection with the positive conclusion.


Limitations of EMDR

Despite its accolades, EMDR has its limitations. Here we address the two major ones: (a) worsening of distress and (b) limited evidence for working with complex trauma.


Worsening of distress

Some clients feel overwhelmed by the sheer intensity of revisiting painful memories. Even after a session, they may still feel raw and disturbed by the images and sensations brought up in an EMDR session. In the worst cases, clients find themselves, ironically, re-traumatised by EMDR. In cases of such adverse experiences with EMDR, clients understandably may not want to continue EMDR sessions, or if they do continue, may go through them feeling helpless. These clients are effectively just "stuck" reliving a distressing event, rather than "flow" through scenes that would eventually lead to a sense of ending and closure.


For trauma to truly process and desensitise, the client have to be firmly grounded in a sense of safety:

  • The therapist must ensure their client can stay in touch with the here-and-now whilst experiencing emotional intensity, without losing themselves or sense of reality. This means working on emotional regulation prior to starting EMDR sessions if necessary. This allows the client to ride through to the end of a processing cycle where it truly feels like the past is in the past.

  • The therapist must be able to provide a sense of unwavering steadiness while maintaining warmth and compassion whilst witnessing their clients undergo heavy emotions or even describe traumatic memories.

  • During the desensitisation phase, the therapist must be ready to intervene if the client feels stuck or loops in a particularly distressing scene. There are a multitude of interventions depending on the nature of the looping.


Working with complex trauma

Much of the talk around EMDR's efficacy tend to refer to its treatment of single-event trauma, i.e. distressing event(s) that are shorter-term and have a relatively clear start and end. These include disasters, isolated incidents of physical and sexual assault, car/traffic/vehicular accidents, combat and war.


In practice with these cases, locating and processing target memories is relatively straightforward (though not necessarily easier or less intense). Similarly, when a client loops in a distressing moment, it is also more straightforward for us therapists to intervene by activating resources, i.e. positive life/relationship experiences outside of their trauma.


Complex trauma on the other hand does not fit into the traditional EMDR protocol. Complex trauma encompasses trauma that tends to be long-term, interpersonal, and/or occurring through childhood. For example, prolonged neglect, deprivation, or abuse in childhood.


The practice of traditional EMDR runs into difficulties in the following areas:

  • Locating target memories: it is common that survivors of complex trauma have difficulty remembering the past – dissociation is our brain's way of protecting us from the full brunt of distress.

  • Containing the processing within the target memory chain: adjacent memory chains may be opened up. As a result, the client may have several memory chains only partially processed, which can lead to feeling overwhelmed without actually reaching the closure of full processing for either. For example, with low self-esteem, the target memory chain could pertain to early childhood experiences with a depressed mother. However, other memory chains pertaining to abuse from a relative might also be activated.

  • Lack of interpersonal safety: survivors of complex trauma, especially those who grew up without safe attachment to a caregiver, may need more sessions working on emotional regulation before beginning EMDR.


Attachment-Focused EMDR for Complex Trauma

AF-EMDR was adapted to address the limitations of traditional EMDR. While traditional EMDR is geared toward single-event traumas, AF-EMDR (a) prioritises building safety and (b) focuses on complex trauma including caregiver bonds, emotional neglect and abandonment. The AF-EMDR protocol differs from EMDR in these three aspects:

  • Resource tapping: use of visualisation and bilateral stimulation to develop new neural networks for safe, positive experiences that were deficient during childhood and developmental years.

  • Extensive resourcing for safety: emphasis on reinforcing positive internal resources, paired with bilateral stimulation, to create safety before diving into distressing memories

  • Attuning to client's needs: prioritises attuning to the client's emotional state over strictly following a clinical protocol. AF-EMDR is reported to "flow" better and more organically.


Conclusion

EMDR was revolutionary in how fast and effective it addresses trauma in comparison to conventional talk-based therapy. AF-EMDR has been further adapted to accommodate more forms of trauma, particularly the relational and interpersonal.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page